• Banner 1
  • Banner 2
  • Banner 3

Mama Lottie's Pub & Grill – Best Handmade Pizza & Southern Flavors in Orange Beach, AL

Mama Lottie’s Pub & Grill in Orange Beach, AL, is a must-visit for pizza lovers seeking fresh, handmade dough and rich, flavorful red sauce. Known for its thin crust and hand-tossed pizzas, this spot’s dedication to quality shines through every bite. The warm, friendly service adds to the charm, with staff going the extra mile—like preparing cheese sauce on request. Beyond pizza, standout items include fried dill pickles, homemade marinara, and the irresistible fried banana pudding. Whether dining in or picking up, Mama Lottie’s delivers delicious, scratch-made comfort food that leaves guests eager to return.

Mama Lottie's Pub & Grill at a glance

  • Address 25405 Perdido Beach Blvd #25, Orange Beach, AL 36561, United States
  • Phone +1 251-403-0828
  • Restaurant type Italian restaurant .

Photos & Gallery

Mama Lottie's Pub & Grill: Reviews & Ratings

james Holt
5

This place is a winner! The owner was so kind and the thin crust pizza was amazing. I asked if they had cheese sauce as I like to dip my pizza crust. No was the answer but a few minutes later his cook whipped up some cheese sauce and it was great! Hope he adds it to the menu. And my gosh, the fried banana pudding was so good! Thanks so much from a first timer. Definitely will be back!

sunny nicholson
5

This pizza is one of the best I have had in Gulf Shores! Highly suggest for the people wanting to do pizza night while vacationing! The service was absolutely top notch too!

Mason & Libby
5

Mama Lottie’s Pub & Grill is the best pizza in the area (maybe of anywhere, honestly)! It’s on the SE end of the building next to T-Mobile and China Dragon. Fresh handmade dough and sauce with quality ingredients. Best red sauce we’ve ever had - I wish I could bottle it up and bring it home! One size pizza easily serves two people and is a great price. They mainly make hand tossed but can do thin crust as well. They’re newly opened (existing name but new owners/operators), and it’s SO worth the stop to dine in or pickup! Plenty of seating, friendly and fast service, and delicious food. GO TO MAMA LOTTIE’S NEXT TO T-MOBILE!

Cherri Allen
5

We’ve already had our seafood meal and wanted something different tonight……..pizza! Mama Lottie’s Pub and Grill had great reviews, so that was our destination. We were not disappointed! Fried dill pickles fresh house salad and Mama Lottie’s Lotta Love pizza! They’ve not had this location open very long and Matt was quick to let us know hey still have things to do, but that will not be a problem in serving delicious, fresh, made from scratch food and he was right! He’s very personable and made sure we were happy with our food……….yes, extremely happy! We left with an order of cheese bread and homemade marinara for a late night snack! Matt, the best to you and can’t wait to come back the next time we are in Orange Beach and have more of your delicious creations!

Shannon Hurst
5

Our last dinner before heading home and it didn't disappoint! The food was fabulous! My husband is picky about pizza and he loved it. We ordered two pizzas, but easily could've shared one. Order the cheesesticks. You'll be glad you did!

Misty Rauschuber
5

Don’t let the lack of reviews keep you from coming to this amazing place!! We took a chance on this newly opened business and are so glad we did! We started with the garlic bread, then I had the Pepperoni Calzone and my husband had the Meatball Sub. Everything was amazing! The marinara sauce is so flavorful and the calzone bread was perfect. We forgot to take pictures before we started. The picture is only a half of the calzone and as you can see my husband was making his sub disappear. His meatballs were huge and had the best flavor. You won’t regret stopping by M-Saturday 4pm-9pm!

Alyssa Ballew
5

Came here tonight, because they had very good reviews. The pizza was so good and the owners are so nice. Next time we are at the beach, we will be back.

Location

  • Mama Lottie's Pub & Grill
    Mama Lottie's Pub & Grill
    25405 Perdido Beach Blvd #25, Orange Beach, AL 36561, United States Hotline: +1 251-403-0828

Mama Lottie’s Pub & Grill, nestled on Perdido Beach Blvd in Orange Beach, Alabama, is rapidly earning its reputation as a must-visit local gem. This newly operated spot brings a fresh breath to the dining landscape, with an emphasis on hand-crafted, from-scratch dishes that speak to both quality and care.

The highlight here is undoubtedly the pizza. With fresh handmade dough and a rich, vibrant red sauce that many wish they could bottle, Mama Lottie’s elevates what pizza means in Gulf Shores and beyond. Whether you prefer a thin crust or hand tossed, each pie is expertly crafted, serving as an ideal meal for two and priced with great value in mind. The praise from patrons who rave about the thin crust’s crispness and the bold sauce is well deserved.

Beyond pizza, Mama Lottie’s offers unique favorites like fried dill pickles and their famous fried banana pudding—comfort food with a creative twist. The homemade marinara and cheesesticks are also standouts, highly recommended by regulars for their fresh flavors and satisfying textures.

What sets this pub & grill apart is not just its menu but the warmth of its service. Guests consistently highlight the friendly, personal touch from the staff and ownership, making every visit feel welcoming and memorable. The owner’s willingness to accommodate special requests, like whipping up cheese sauce on the spot, showcases their commitment to guest satisfaction.

The inviting atmosphere with plenty of seating encourages both cozy dinners and casual pickups, ideal for travelers and locals alike. Whether stopping by for a quick bite or a leisurely meal, Mama Lottie’s Pub & Grill offers a delicious, heartfelt dining experience that’s hard to beat in Orange Beach.